Royal Navy officer's grandfathers fought on OPPOSITE sides of WW2

Royal Navy officer's grandfathers fought on OPPOSITE sides of WW2

March 27, 2021

My grandfathers fought on OPPOSITE sides of World War Two: One of Royal Navy officer’s ancestors was an Iron-Cross winning U-Boat crewman while the other was on a British destroyer

  • Ben Hoffmeister, 23, from Oxford, is setting sail for the Mediterranean next week
  • His grandfathers served on opposing sides of Battle of the Atlantic during WW2
  • Ernest Hoffmeister determined to keep UK sea lanes open in Atlantic and Arctic
  • Meanwhile Erwin Menzel crewed U-boat determined to strangle Britain’s lifelines

A Royal Navy officer is setting sail inspired by the wartime exploits of his grandfathers who served on opposing sides in the Second World War.

Sub Lieutenant Ben Hoffmeister, 23, from Oxford, is following in the footsteps of the two men in pursuing a life at sea. He will be aboard new patrol ship HMS Trent as it sets off for the Mediterranean next week.

Hoffmeister’s grandfathers fought on both sides in the Battle of the Atlantic.

Ernest Hoffmeister served in the Atlantic and Arctic determined to keep the UK’s sea lanes open, while Sub Lieutenant Hoffmeister’s maternal grandfather Erwin Menzel crewed a U-boat determined to strangle Britain’s lifelines.


Sub Lieutenant Ben Hoffmeister’s grandfathers, Ernest Hoffmeister (pictured left) and Erwin Menzel (right) fought on both sides of the Battle of the Atlantic during the Second World War

Hoffmeister (pictured above, in a handout photo issued by the Royal Navy), 23, from Oxford, will be aboard new patrol ship HMS Trent as it sets off for the Mediterranean next week

After completing training as a mechanical engineer, Mr Menzel was assigned to U-963 and sailed on 10 patrols out of bases in Norway and France in the final two years of the war.

This included a failed attempt to attack the Normandy invasion armada in June 1944.

Although a stoker, Mr Menzel manned one of the submarine’s anti-aircraft guns and was awarded the coveted Iron Cross for his part in an action against an RAF Liberator bomber – frequently the scourge of U-boats.

The submarine was eventually scuttled off the village of Nazare in Portugal 12 days after VE Day and Mr Menzel was taken prisoner with his shipmates.

A handout photo issued by the Royal Navy of U-963 arriving in Portugal. Mr Menzel was assigned to U-963 and sailed on 10 patrols out of bases in Norway and France in the final two years of the war

A HMT King Sol on the Mersey. Mr Hoffmeister was assigned to the Royal Naval Patrol Service after completing his training as a coder, serving with a converted trawler, HMT King Sol, in the Atlantic and Arctic

‘Had we lost, there wouldn’t have been a D-Day’: Battle of the Atlantic ‘fundamental’ to the outcome of the Second World War, says historian 

The Allies’ victory in the Battle of the Atlantic was ‘fundamental’ to the outcome of the Second World War, according to a historian.

Speaking on how important the battle was, Jonathan Dimbleby, who wrote Battle of the Atlantic: How the Allies Won the War, told HistoryExtra: ‘It was fundamental. 

‘The Atlantic was the route by which all resources came to Britain, without which the country would have collapsed. 

‘Had we lost the battle, we wouldn’t have had enough weapons – nor the industrial capacity to make weapons – and American troops would not have been able to get across for D-Day.

‘In fact, there wouldn’t have been a D-Day.’

Winston Churchill described the Battle of the Atlantic as ‘the dominating factor all through the war’, as control of Atlantic shipping routes was central to the British war effort.

The naval blockade of Germany started the day after war was declared in September 1939, and did not officially end until VE Day in May 1945, after 35,000 Allied troops had been killed in the battle. 

It saw the Royal Navy and the RAF, allied with U.S. forces, contend against German U-boats and the Luftwaffe to allow supplies and materials to reach Britain.

Fighting reached a peak in the spring of 1943, as the Allies took the upper hand thanks to new technology such as radar and longer-range aircraft.      

He subsequently emigrated to Britain, where he settled down.

Sub Lieutenant Hoffmeister’s paternal grandfather Mr Hoffmeister was assigned to the Royal Naval Patrol Service after completing his training as a coder, serving with a converted trawler, HMT King Sol, in the Atlantic and Arctic before transferring to a destroyer based in Ceylon (today Sri Lanka) as the war against Japan reached its climax.

He died when Sub Lieutenant Hoffmeister was just 10 – with the future officer too young to have asked the questions he wished he could have about the war.

Sub Lieutenant Hoffmeister said: ‘One of the few stories I remember him talking about was having to climb up the mainmast during the convoys to chip off ice that had accumulated and risked capsizing the vessel.’

As for grandad Erwin, he was, says Sub Lieutenant Hoffmeister, ‘instrumental in raising my interest to join the navy’. 

He added: ‘By the time he died, when I was 17, I had already decided I was going to join the Royal Navy.’

It is unlikely, given where their vessels served and when, that his grandfathers faced each other in the Atlantic or Arctic, but his parents were nevertheless somewhat nervous when they met for the first time.

‘They got on incredibly well when they eventually met,’ he says. 

‘It seemed the shared experience of the Battle of the Atlantic was more important to them than which side of the war they had fought it on.

‘That legacy is perhaps the most important aspect to take away from their story.’

And that post-war friendship will be echoed on Trent’s deployment when she works side-by-side with the German Navy on Nato duties on Operation Sea Guardian, the alliance’s counter-terrorism mission in the Mediterranean.

Lieutenant Commander David Webber, in charge of Trent’s marine engineering department, said: ‘It’s an interesting story from the perspective of how far Europe has come, with Ben now serving in the Royal Navy on a ship that will work alongside the modern Deutsche Marine.

‘His family history acutely tracks the human impact of the history of 20th century Europe: World War 2, the division of Europe in the Cold War, reunification and co-operation.’

Mr Menzel, pictured above, manned one of the submarine’s anti-aircraft guns and was awarded the coveted Iron Cross for his part in an action against an RAF Liberator bomber

Hoffmeister, who is is following in the footsteps of his two grandfathers in pursuing a life at sea, will set sail aboard HMS Trent, pictured above

Source: Read Full Article