The varied scoring was so blatant that even host Phillip Schofield interrupted proceedings to inspect Jason's scoring system and make sure he had the ability to dish out higher scores.
Tonight's episode of Dancing on Ice saw Jason give Loose Women panellist Saira Khan and Love Island star Wes Nelson identical scores – despite his fellow judges all disagreeing with his verdicts.
Viewers flocked to social media to give their take on the scoring board with only a small few defending Jason's judging credentials while many called for him to be sacked from the panel.
One fan tweeted: "Why is Jason Gardiner so far off from the other judges? Is he determined to be a complete numpty!"
Another put: "I think Jason needs his scoring judgement re calibrating."
A third ranted: "Any chance the public can vote Jason off tonight?"